@mrzz interested in hearing your response to a friend of mine who spent years in Brazil and speaks fluently. Fancies himself as a Brazil expert. Credit trader. For context, he and I have been arguing about the whole coronavirus thing since day 1. He's one of those who believes that there is a massive over-reaction. Here's what he said to me today, when I said that I thought Bolsonaro was crazy...
He isn't as crazy as the press would have you believe
Don't listen to people in Rio
Makes Chicago look like heaven
He took over a country on the edge of bankruptcy
With a murder rate of 80k a year
Rio is over
The PT have sucked that tit to desacation
I agree he says tasteless things and has no filter
But, what he is trying to do with his political, tax and economic reforms are necessary
Rio was a thriving market, most managers have moved to SP
In a nutshell, your friend is, best case scenario, some stubborn idiot that is doubling down his bets as he has no other way to confront factual reality. Worst case scenario he is the greatest retard of all time. The expected shortfall in his case it is just some dumb parrot thinking about his own ass and nothing more.
Ok, let's debunk it, phrase by phrase:
"
He isn't as crazy as the press would have you believe"
He is. All that I have been posting is factual data. You know I check things before I post. He is breaking social distancing almost on a daily basis, against the advice of his own minister of health. His ministers almost instantly walk back or deny what he claims. His vice-president contradicts him explicitly. His own position (and wording of his positions) changes by the day. This has nothing to do with the press, unless the press is able to do this all with computer graphics.
"
Don't listen to people in Rio"
As much as I don't like Rio, it is a 10 million people city. So we just don't listen, right. People there are worried because, surprise surprise, there is the capital of little tiny tiny little Brazilian problem called FAVELAS, where MILLIONS live packed together with poor sanitary conditions. And, maybe, just maybe, if Covid-19 spreads through there it could be a major public health problem. But, yeah, don't listen to them.
"
Makes Chicago look like heaven"
I would love to know Chicago -- I love the Blues. He probably got this one right. Problem is that it is exactly because this is true that the former assertion is false.
"
He took over a country on the edge of bankruptcy"
Factually wrong. Temer, the guy who assumed when Dilma was impeached, took a country in the edge of bankruptcy (two years before him). Actually the real edge of bankruptcy was even before the impeachment, the own PT government was forced by congress to curb public spending. He got a country in bad economical shape? Yes. It is fucking Brazil if he haven't noticed before. And what the fuck this has to do with shitty crisis management?
"
With a murder rate of 80k a year"
50 k. Get your fucking facts straight.
"
Rio is over"
I think he means "finished". Yes, Rio is the main drive for the number above. Strangely enough Bolsonaro (electoral) home state. He was a congressman representing Rio for almost 30 years. He shares the blame.
"
The PT have sucked that tit to desacation"
PT sucks massively, in a lot of different ways. But, again, factually incorrect. Rio is crime infested since forever.
"
I agree he says tasteless things and has no filter"
This is the smallest problem. Nobody, NOBODY is complaining about tasteless things now. People are complaining about senseless, baseless things. People are complaining about contradictory things.
"
But, what he is trying to do with his political, tax and economic reforms are necessary"
Not "his" reforms. ZERO of those reforms are "his" reforms. EVERYTHING started on the previous government (Temer). And given his profound political inability, a lot of sensitive issues are not being discussed. One of the few aspects of his political campaign that I agree with partially (privatization, leaving health and education out of it) is not being pushed hard enough, and his "super-minister" said before the election that he didn't like the previous privatization model, from former president FHC, which was EXTREMELY successful. Actually, the lack of privatizations is a clear broken promise, how the hell guys from the market are not complaining I don't know.
"
Rio was a thriving market, most managers have moved to SP"
So what? I live in fucking SP. "Managers" here live with a target on their backs. If I had real money I would NEVER live here. But, what the fuck this has to do with the conversation?
Ok, I was just being a pain in the ass with the answers. But I will use an argument that surely will resonate with you: Bolsonaro main talking point is the economy. Right, the problem is that he only started talking about the economy in MID MARCH!!!! This fucking shit is on the news AT LEAST from January. I was in south east asia back in January, my browser history shows that, on January 14th, I was studying the flights out of Wuhan, to check if the pandemic would reach me before I would go back. The epidemiologists here were planning for it by that time as well. What the fuck was he doing?
He clearly, CLEARLY, only realized the impact when governors started to lock down. How fucking dumb is that?
Do you wanna know my (real) opinion about how he is managing this: he is simply doubting everything. He thinks that all, or the absolute majority of doctors and biologists in the world are colluding with the world press to take over the world. That doctors here, exhausted after long and long hours fighting the usual lack of conditions here AND the beginning of the pandemic, are falsifying data (by the way, it does not even work that way). He is stupid AND disconnected to reality. His voters, struggling to face the shame, are simply in denial. All they can say is that PT was worst. I don't give a flying fuck about PT. Honestly, fuck this people.
PS/EDIT: Sorry all for the rent. Probably a lot of misspells and typos above, no time to revise it.