Stanford

Calvy

Masters Champion
Joined
Apr 24, 2013
Messages
905
Reactions
0
Points
0
djmm said:
Okay, if we take away Serena's power, we'll have to take away Aggie's ability to run!! Doesn't sound right, does it :huh:

Nice retort.....:clap
 

tossip

Grand Slam Champion
Joined
Apr 15, 2013
Messages
7,297
Reactions
2,600
Points
113
10sfan said:
I agree Aga has no chance against a power hitter who can execute, but how often do they play at the top of their game? Aga has way more than defense. Woz is a defender. Kerber a defender. Aga defends, but also has huge variety and constructs smart points. Ciby won because she was playing near her best. A heavy hitter playing at that level can crush someone with little power regardless of high tennis IQ. This is why Aga routinely loses to the big three but usually beats the rest of the field.

Who has higher tennis IQ? Serena or Aga? Take away Setena's power and have them play a match. That would be interesting. I am not a fan or anti-fan of either so do not take this to be an insult to Serena. Just wanting to get insights from people who understand the game better than I do.
Serena has high tennis IQ and the tennis media never gives her credit.She turned around matches that looked lost without her coach giving her on court tips.She has the ability to change the course of the match ,good example was the USA Open final at 5-4 with Vika serving for the match..against Vika in Australia qtrs 2010..against Justine AO10...her ability to win close matches or turning around matches is genius.
 

special700

Masters Champion
Joined
Jul 3, 2013
Messages
927
Reactions
1
Points
16
tossip said:
10sfan said:
I agree Aga has no chance against a power hitter who can execute, but how often do they play at the top of their game? Aga has way more than defense. Woz is a defender. Kerber a defender. Aga defends, but also has huge variety and constructs smart points. Ciby won because she was playing near her best. A heavy hitter playing at that level can crush someone with little power regardless of high tennis IQ. This is why Aga routinely loses to the big three but usually beats the rest of the field.

Who has higher tennis IQ? Serena or Aga? Take away Setena's power and have them play a match. That would be interesting. I am not a fan or anti-fan of either so do not take this to be an insult to Serena. Just wanting to get insights from people who understand the game better than I do.
Serena has high tennis IQ and the tennis media never gives her credit.She turned around matches that looked lost without her coach giving her on court tips.She has the ability to change the course of the match ,good example was the USA Open final at 5-4 with Vika serving for the match..against Vika in Australia qtrs 2010..against Justine AO10...her ability to win close matches or turning around matches is genius.

They will never acknowledge that fact.
 

tossip

Grand Slam Champion
Joined
Apr 15, 2013
Messages
7,297
Reactions
2,600
Points
113
Serena has outwitted the best coaches in the tennis world,from Hogstedt,Vika s coach,Sven from Adidas,Carlos Rodrigues,Ricardo Sanchez e.g Serena vs Petrova Rome 2012,Yuri Sharapov,Joyce,Darren Cahill and Na li and Jie Zheng s husbands...she beat all these players and their coaches.That must be humiliating for these men...after pova got on court coaching at 3-2 in that 2nd set during that final in Miami she never won a game after that,Serena threw that bagel right into Hogstedt face...kinda like eat that...lol
 

Fiero425

The GOAT
Joined
Jul 23, 2013
Messages
11,512
Reactions
2,576
Points
113
Location
Chicago, IL
Website
fiero4251.blogspot.com
special700 said:
tossip said:
10sfan said:
I agree Aga has no chance against a power hitter who can execute, but how often do they play at the top of their game? Aga has way more than defense. Woz is a defender. Kerber a defender. Aga defends, but also has huge variety and constructs smart points. Ciby won because she was playing near her best. A heavy hitter playing at that level can crush someone with little power regardless of high tennis IQ. This is why Aga routinely loses to the big three but usually beats the rest of the field.

Who has higher tennis IQ? Serena or Aga? Take away Setena's power and have them play a match. That would be interesting. I am not a fan or anti-fan of either so do not take this to be an insult to Serena. Just wanting to get insights from people who understand the game better than I do.
Serena has high tennis IQ and the tennis media never gives her credit.She turned around matches that looked lost without her coach giving her on court tips.She has the ability to change the course of the match ,good example was the USA Open final at 5-4 with Vika serving for the match..against Vika in Australia qtrs 2010..against Justine AO10...her ability to win close matches or turning around matches is genius.

They will never acknowledge that fact.

If her IQ is so high, why does she get into battles with players we don't even know? Please spare us all this intelligence quotient on the court concerning Serena! She's so much better athletically, why 3 sets against anyone; esp. Radwanska on grass? How does that happen unless you're mindlessly wandering around the court, commiting UFE after UFE for no good reason? :nono :shy: :huh:
 

djmm

Pro Tour Champion
Joined
Jul 18, 2013
Messages
380
Reactions
2
Points
18
Location
New Jersey
Serena can't win them all, and it's harder to play someone you've never played or studied before!!

As for these UFEs you're ranting about, I think you're confusing Serena's game with Venus'. Serena rarely makes UFEs!! She has mastered this sport mentally and physically, and it shows!! :clap
 

10isfan

Major Winner
Joined
Apr 16, 2013
Messages
1,944
Reactions
399
Points
83
Sorry, taking away Aga's ability to run is not a good retort. I never said Aga is a better player than Serena. No one can claim that. Serena is better than every other female on the planet. I questioned who as higher tennis IQ. The only way to answer that is to imagine how Serena would play if she had the same power as Aga. Tossip is citing examples of when Serena was able to turn around matches. That could be good evidence to support Serena's intelligence. However, did she use smarts to do that or did her game start clicking again after a few bad games?
 

Fiero425

The GOAT
Joined
Jul 23, 2013
Messages
11,512
Reactions
2,576
Points
113
Location
Chicago, IL
Website
fiero4251.blogspot.com
10sfan said:
Sorry, taking away Aga's ability to run is not a good retort. I never said Aga is a better player than Serena. No one can claim that. Serena is better than every other female on the planet. I questioned who as higher tennis IQ. The only way to answer that is to imagine how Serena would play if she had the same power as Aga. Tossip is citing examples of when Serena was able to turn around matches. That could be good evidence to support Serena's intelligence. However, did she use smarts to do that or did her game start clicking again after a few bad games?

Bravo! :clap :clap :clap :D :blush: :angel:
 

tossip

Grand Slam Champion
Joined
Apr 15, 2013
Messages
7,297
Reactions
2,600
Points
113
Fiero425 said:
special700 said:
tossip said:
10sfan said:
I agree Aga has no chance against a power hitter who can execute, but how often do they play at the top of their game? Aga has way more than defense. Woz is a defender. Kerber a defender. Aga defends, but also has huge variety and constructs smart points. Ciby won because she was playing near her best. A heavy hitter playing at that level can crush someone with little power regardless of high tennis IQ. This is why Aga routinely loses to the big three but usually beats the rest of the field.

Who has higher tennis IQ? Serena or Aga? Take away Setena's power and have them play a match. That would be interesting. I am not a fan or anti-fan of either so do not take this to be an insult to Serena. Just wanting to get insights from people who understand the game better than I do.
Serena has high tennis IQ and the tennis media never gives her credit.She turned around matches that looked lost without her coach giving her on court tips.She has the ability to change the course of the match ,good example was the USA Open final at 5-4 with Vika serving for the match..against Vika in Australia qtrs 2010..against Justine AO10...her ability to win close matches or turning around matches is genius.

They will never acknowledge that fact.

If her IQ is so high, why does she get into battles with players we don't even know? Please spare us all this intelligence quotient on the court concerning Serena! She's so much better athletically, why 3 sets against anyone; esp. Radwanska on grass? How does that happen unless you're mindlessly wandering around the court, commiting UFE after UFE for no good reason? :nono :shy: :huh:
Serena was struggling with confidence after her loss at RG12,after losing early at A012 and Miami and RG12 she was in her first final in a slam after the USA Open 2011 debacle..who knows what she was going through..maybe nerves and flashbacks...she woke up at 3-2 and ran away with the set and match ..
 

djmm

Pro Tour Champion
Joined
Jul 18, 2013
Messages
380
Reactions
2
Points
18
Location
New Jersey
I was saying your scenario doesn't make sense. Period!! You can't take away Serena #1 asset (power) and not take Aggie's best. Only a sucker would take that bet. Plus, there is nothing Aggie does that Serena can't do better, including her tennis IQ!!
 

Fiero425

The GOAT
Joined
Jul 23, 2013
Messages
11,512
Reactions
2,576
Points
113
Location
Chicago, IL
Website
fiero4251.blogspot.com
tossip said:
Fiero425 said:
special700 said:
tossip said:
10sfan said:
I agree Aga has no chance against a power hitter who can execute, but how often do they play at the top of their game? Aga has way more than defense. Woz is a defender. Kerber a defender. Aga defends, but also has huge variety and constructs smart points. Ciby won because she was playing near her best. A heavy hitter playing at that level can crush someone with little power regardless of high tennis IQ. This is why Aga routinely loses to the big three but usually beats the rest of the field.

Who has higher tennis IQ? Serena or Aga? Take away Setena's power and have them play a match. That would be interesting. I am not a fan or anti-fan of either so do not take this to be an insult to Serena. Just wanting to get insights from people who understand the game better than I do.
Serena has high tennis IQ and the tennis media never gives her credit.She turned around matches that looked lost without her coach giving her on court tips.She has the ability to change the course of the match ,good example was the USA Open final at 5-4 with Vika serving for the match..against Vika in Australia qtrs 2010..against Justine AO10...her ability to win close matches or turning around matches is genius.

They will never acknowledge that fact.

If her IQ is so high, why does she get into battles with players we don't even know? Please spare us all this intelligence quotient on the court concerning Serena! She's so much better athletically, why 3 sets against anyone; esp. Radwanska on grass? How does that happen unless you're mindlessly wandering around the court, commiting UFE after UFE for no good reason? :nono :shy: :huh:
Serena was struggling with confidence after her loss at RG12,after losing early at A012 and Miami and RG12 she was in her first final in a slam after the USA Open 2011 debacle..who knows what she was going through..maybe nerves and flashbacks...she woke up at 3-2 and ran away with the set and match ..

Well that's something and makes more sense than blind loyalty! Thanks! :clap :angel:
 

tossip

Grand Slam Champion
Joined
Apr 15, 2013
Messages
7,297
Reactions
2,600
Points
113
10sfan said:
Sorry, taking away Aga's ability to run is not a good retort. I never said Aga is a better player than Serena. No one can claim that. Serena is better than every other female on the planet. I questioned who as higher tennis IQ. The only way to answer that is to imagine how Serena would play if she had the same power as Aga. Tossip is citing examples of when Serena was able to turn around matches. That could be good evidence to support Serena's intelligence. However, did she use smarts to do that or did her game start clicking again after a few bad games?
tennis is a mental game and she has smarts to realize that she has to change tactics mid match to win...like that 2nd set against pova in Miami,during that changeover after pova broke she was probably thinking about ways to get back into the match and never looked back after breaking back..that takes smarts to fight pova and Hogstedt and bageling in the process.:snigger
 

djmm

Pro Tour Champion
Joined
Jul 18, 2013
Messages
380
Reactions
2
Points
18
Location
New Jersey
Before you start bragging on Aggie's IQ, she needs to put it to good use and win a slam first!! To even discuss it is ludacris and pure nonsense!! :idea: You are just trying to knock Serena down. Sorry, we don't play that!!


Fiero425 said:
tossip said:
Fiero425 said:
special700 said:
tossip said:
Serena has high tennis IQ and the tennis media never gives her credit.She turned around matches that looked lost without her coach giving her on court tips.She has the ability to change the course of the match ,good example was the USA Open final at 5-4 with Vika serving for the match..against Vika in Australia qtrs 2010..against Justine AO10...her ability to win close matches or turning around matches is genius.

They will never acknowledge that fact.

If her IQ is so high, why does she get into battles with players we don't even know? Please spare us all this intelligence quotient on the court concerning Serena! She's so much better athletically, why 3 sets against anyone; esp. Radwanska on grass? How does that happen unless you're mindlessly wandering around the court, commiting UFE after UFE for no good reason? :nono :shy: :huh:
Serena was struggling with confidence after her loss at RG12,after losing early at A012 and Miami and RG12 she was in her first final in a slam after the USA Open 2011 debacle..who knows what she was going through..maybe nerves and flashbacks...she woke up at 3-2 and ran away with the set and match ..

Well that's something and makes more sense than blind loyalty! Thanks! :clap :angel:

You talking about me??

Watch yourself; I know this game ... and so does Serena!! I'm not blinded by anything. I tell it how it is, straight up with NO biases!!

**it's getting hot in here**
 

special700

Masters Champion
Joined
Jul 3, 2013
Messages
927
Reactions
1
Points
16
If her IQ is so high, why does she get into battles with players we don't even know? Please spare us all this intelligence quotient on the court concerning Serena! She's so much better athletically, why 3 sets against anyone; esp. Radwanska on grass? How does that happen unless you're mindlessly wandering around the court, commiting UFE after UFE for no good reason?

You are kidding when you ask that question....Right? Please tell me you are. If Aggie has such a high tennis IQ why the heck hasn't she won a major yet. And what happened yesterday....See two can play the same game. Remember Serena has 16 majors plus doubles and 4 Gold medals plus many more. Apparently you have not watch many of Serena's matches. "Why 3 sets" that is such a stupid questions:s
 

Fiero425

The GOAT
Joined
Jul 23, 2013
Messages
11,512
Reactions
2,576
Points
113
Location
Chicago, IL
Website
fiero4251.blogspot.com
special700 said:
If her IQ is so high, why does she get into battles with players we don't even know? Please spare us all this intelligence quotient on the court concerning Serena! She's so much better athletically, why 3 sets against anyone; esp. Radwanska on grass? How does that happen unless you're mindlessly wandering around the court, commiting UFE after UFE for no good reason?

You are kidding when you ask that question....Right? Please tell me you are. If Aggie has such a high tennis IQ why the heck hasn't she won a major yet. And what happened yesterday....See two can play the same game. Remember Serena has 16 majors plus doubles and 4 Gold medals plus many more. Apparently you have not watch many of Serena's matches. "Why 3 sets" that is such a stupid questions:s

You must have me mixed up with someone else! I never said Aza had a high IQ on court! She's one of those mindless players who just bash the ball as far as I'm concerned! She scares players more with all the noises coming out of her for the simplest of shots; including drops! It's unwatchable for the most part! Most of the ladies do it and I've been wondering when the WTA is going to start cracking down on all that stuff on court? It's all been a pipedream saying it's being "grandfathered" in with the new and younger players! Total BS so far; getting worse from what I can tell! Sciavone, Aza, Sharapova, and so many more need mufflers on their mouthes!
 

Calvy

Masters Champion
Joined
Apr 24, 2013
Messages
905
Reactions
0
Points
0
Fiero425 said:
special700 said:
tossip said:
10sfan said:
I agree Aga has no chance against a power hitter who can execute, but how often do they play at the top of their game? Aga has way more than defense. Woz is a defender. Kerber a defender. Aga defends, but also has huge variety and constructs smart points. Ciby won because she was playing near her best. A heavy hitter playing at that level can crush someone with little power regardless of high tennis IQ. This is why Aga routinely loses to the big three but usually beats the rest of the field.

Who has higher tennis IQ? Serena or Aga? Take away Setena's power and have them play a match. That would be interesting. I am not a fan or anti-fan of either so do not take this to be an insult to Serena. Just wanting to get insights from people who understand the game better than I do.
Serena has high tennis IQ and the tennis media never gives her credit.She turned around matches that looked lost without her coach giving her on court tips.She has the ability to change the course of the match ,good example was the USA Open final at 5-4 with Vika serving for the match..against Vika in Australia qtrs 2010..against Justine AO10...her ability to win close matches or turning around matches is genius.

They will never acknowledge that fact.

If her IQ is so high, why does she get into battles with players we don't even know? Please spare us all this intelligence quotient on the court concerning Serena! She's so much better athletically, why 3 sets against anyone; esp. Radwanska on grass? How does that happen unless you're mindlessly wandering around the court, commiting UFE after UFE for no good reason? :nono :shy: :huh:

It's called NERVES, and the older you get, the more they seem to take hold. And as far as losing a set at Wimbledon to Radwanska, remind me, who won that match. As far as her battles with little known player's, even her biggest critics will tell you, she tends to play lazy tennis against the lower ranked players. If athletics was it took to win as much as Serena won, then Kim C., Elena D., Caroline W, and countless other players would have won more slams, or won slams.
 

special700

Masters Champion
Joined
Jul 3, 2013
Messages
927
Reactions
1
Points
16
Fiero425 said:
special700 said:
If her IQ is so high, why does she get into battles with players we don't even know? Please spare us all this intelligence quotient on the court concerning Serena! She's so much better athletically, why 3 sets against anyone; esp. Radwanska on grass? How does that happen unless you're mindlessly wandering around the court, commiting UFE after UFE for no good reason?

You are kidding when you ask that question....Right? Please tell me you are. If Aggie has such a high tennis IQ why the heck hasn't she won a major yet. And what happened yesterday....See two can play the same game. Remember Serena has 16 majors plus doubles and 4 Gold medals plus many more. Apparently you have not watch many of Serena's matches. "Why 3 sets" that is such a stupid questions:s

You must have me mixed up with someone else! I never said Aza had a high IQ on court! She's one of those mindless players who just bash the ball as far as I'm concerned! She scares players more with all the noises coming out of her for the simplest of shots; including drops! It's unwatchable for the most part! Most of the ladies do it and I've been wondering when the WTA is going to start cracking down on all that stuff on court? It's all been a pipedream saying it's being "grandfathered" in with the new and younger players! Total BS so far; getting worse from what I can tell! Sciavone, Aza, Sharapova, and so many more need mufflers on their mouthes!

F425 that was not a reply to you. On this board you do not know who you are replying to everything seems to be one big post.
 

10isfan

Major Winner
Joined
Apr 16, 2013
Messages
1,944
Reactions
399
Points
83
Thanks, Tossip. You are posting rational arguments to support Serena. My response to others is that Aga has not won a major because she lacks power. Tennis has become a power game. If a power player can hit her shots, finesse players can do nothing but watch the winners go by. If you doubt my statement, consider how successful Pova is. She is not known for her tennis smarts yet has four slams.
 

RJD11

Major Winner
Joined
Jul 11, 2013
Messages
1,063
Reactions
0
Points
0
Location
Louisiana
10sfan said:
Sorry, taking away Aga's ability to run is not a good retort. I never said Aga is a better player than Serena. No one can claim that. Serena is better than every other female on the planet. I questioned who as higher tennis IQ. The only way to answer that is to imagine how Serena would play if she had the same power as Aga. Tossip is citing examples of when Serena was able to turn around matches. That could be good evidence to support Serena's intelligence. However, did she use smarts to do that or did her game start clicking again after a few bad games?

You can have all the talent in the world and if you don't

know how to use it effectively the talent is useless.

A lot of players now a days hit the ball hard. But they don't

do what Serena does.

One has to be smart enough to adapt and change your game

when things are not going your way. There is no way

Serena could do that as many times as she has by being

a mindless ball basher. She has Talent and brains.