DarthFed said:
Out of curiosity what did you see as the bad subplots this season? The only thing I thought could have been more interesting was Jaime and Bronn's travels to Dorne, but even that finished with a flurry. Arya's transition into a "faceless" assassin was pretty boring but that seemed unavoidable. I'm not sure what would have made that more interesting. And again it progressed in a major way last night.
Everything that happened in Dorne fell so flat throughout the season, with the exception of the final kiss of death, which was well handled. But the part where Marcella tells Jaime she's happy he's her father was a major "meeeeeeeeh" moment for me. It felt way too forced. She hasn't seen him in years and seemed indifferent to him. Now she's happy her uncle banged her mother and she was the result just so they could share this last fatherly love moment before she dies? It felt too forced.
I thought the Stannis stuff was poorly executed throughout the season as well. Yes, burning his daughter was an act of desperation (and I don't care that it apparently deviated from the book) but it was so out of nowhere and uncharacteristic. It felt purely there for shock value. And one thing I loved about this show for the first 4 seasons is, despite the horrific events that happen, very little came off as purely for shock value. That, unfortunately, was.
Then after such a slow build to Stannis' march to Winterfel they rush the hell out of that and again, it falls so flat.
The Arya stuff was boring throughout the season but I never minded it that much because there was little way to make that exciting, but the payoff was pretty satisfying so I have no complaints there.
Also, as someone pointed out above, Danny is becoming super boring and quite irritating. Though at least that changed with that awesome last scene in episode 9 and whatever it is the Dothraki will do with her.
I'm bitter about Jon dying, though that's Martin's "fault." Nevertheless, despite not reading the books, I feel it's one shocking death too many. Don't get me wrong, it makes sense, because the male Starks have proven to be morons and terrible at politics, but the show/books are losing literally every character people are invested in and despite the rich universe and wide array of interesting characters, it's a very risky path to completely detach yourself from season 1/book 1. I mean, as each character bites the dust, you want people like Cersei, Tyrion, Danny, Arya and Jon Snow to remind you that "hey, this is still the same show that started in season 1."
Don't get me wrong, I love the character evolution. No show does it as well (few shows do anything as well as anything GOT does), but even as a major fanboy of the show, I'm growing a touch numb to certain things and that's not a good sign.
I was heartbroken when Ned Star, Robb Stark and Oberyn died. I was bitter when Jon Snow died, and not in a good way. It's not the same.
Again, this could be purely a personal issue, but a lot of people have been pretty critical of this season, though much of the criticism is BS (the criticism of the Ramsey-Sansa rape scene is nonsensical. Really? THAT is going too far? Have you seen this show? That one scene actually made sense).
Also, at some point, you grow weary as a viewer when you know there's not even naïve hope to latch on to. Everyone you like will die, everyone that is good will die, and there's not even a glimmer of hope. Though that's also why this show works. But at some point, you do need at least a few moments of temporary closure to balance things out. You don't want to feel that the writers are sadistic for the sake of torturing you as a viewer.
To be clear, this season was still better than most seasons most other shows produce. But I'm purely judging it by Game of Thrones standards. With that said, I can't believe I have to wait another year. Now THAT is heartbreaking. Still by far the best show on television, and comfortably the best ever. I just really hope they rebound well.