I'm not sure how I'm trying to have my cake and eat it though. Yes I believe Roger was affected by mono. I believe it impacted his annual routine of practicing in the spring and his form was off for the rest of the year. I really believe that. And his performances throughout 2008 bear that out. Am I saying that he had mono when he was getting tuned? No. I haven't said that. Rafa beat him fair and square in RG. I have complaints about the match being extended past about 2 - 2 in the 5th set at Wimbledon. I agree with DF that he was shite in the first 2 sets. Even Roger has talked about how he had such a loss of confidence facing Rafa in the final after being crushed in RG, I don't know why you have an issue with that. I have never said that Rafa didn't deserve to win that match. Never. Is that the same as your implying that Rafa would have beaten Soderling in 09 if he didn't have knee issues? I would say not.
That's excuse making. El Dude was kind enough to post a link of highlights of that match and what any neutral observer would tell you is that Rafa was hitting the ball short to absolutely the worst opponent to do that to in those conditions and he paid for it. He could have had bionic knees and he wasn't getting to those balls. You can delude yourself all you want. But to simplistically say that I'm trying to have my cake and eat it? Nah... I don't write posts saying that if Roger's back had been fine in last year's USO he would have won. He lost. I"m over it. I
do berate him for putting himself in that position. But then there's you, saying that Rafa would have beaten Stan at the AO after getting crushed in the first set. Despite what was in plain view. I could forgive your initial excuse making, because none of us knew who Sftanimal was at the time. But even now I get the sense you want to come up with that woulda coulda stuff about that match. I don't do that. I don't argue in the face of overwhelming evidence, even if I probably have more justification seeing as Roger
is a more accomplished winner than Rafa. But then I guess it's easier for me to get over losses, maybe that's what sets Fed fans apart from Rafa fans