Amazes me how long they keep their jobs for too. BBC here have had loads of complaints about Castle but ignore them. It's like they have a little club going and they seem untouchable. John Inverdale is another, not sure if you would see him. He commented that Bartoli wasn't much of a looker when she won Wimbledon - shock horror complaints in buckets but he's still doing tennis. I love the old style commentary where you got a verbal picture of the game and some technical insight.
Just got the last bit of Novak Goffin, typically a short match when I was hoping to see a third set. Nole looked better than I've seen him in ages. I am sorry for Goffin, I like his game but he seems to have been completely outplayed. Its a big ask to come in cold I guess and it is a very oppressive arena.
I think
that is their job. To build up a super hero and to tear other players down. Tennis is always looking for a "breakout" star and in the absence of one they'll create one. It's a long, never-ending narrative. It can't be a coincidence that so many of them share the same brain. People complaining doesn't faze them because they're able to get their narrative across and even get some people to argue about their talking points. It's a joke really, but hey, if people fall for it that's their fault. I noticed that a long time ago when I saw different nationalities repeating the same garbage verbatim, and if you don't fall it people think you're crazy.
Back in the day it wasn't necessary to do that, Borg, McEnroe, Nastase did that on their own based on their personality, style, fieriness, etc. They enjoyed the attention that it brought to tennis so now they manufacture in their own crude way.
Nowadays there's very little technical insight just a lot of blather about what players do wrong, their quirks, their innermost thoughts and their attempts to sway public opinion. It works though, so they keep doing it.
Goffin had to come in cold. Annacone admitted that they didn't know when he'd even gotten the call because of Tomas's pullout. He'd never played in the arena before and it would be a bit ask. Sound commentary for a change. He's about the only one I'll listen to, that's because he spews less hyperbole than the rest of them.