You would do well to read Mary's very compassionate post of the topic above. It's very likely he had shingles at the AO, or at least straight after, and then tennis elbow. Both of which things gave him a terrible running start to the year. That with the pressure, and heading into the clay, he didn't have much chance to make a great show of his year, though, as you said, he did make something of RG. You'll be as hard on him as you like...I can't make a generous person out of you...but there are reasons that he had such a bad start.