Denisovich said:
El Dude said:
I can't remember a player who has such a fluctuating level as Monfils. Sometimes he looks like an elite player, sometimes a total mess. One player that comes to mind is Dolgopolov.
Yeah they are similar in that sense. Although Dolgopolov is almost always a total mess and only rarely an elite player.
My thoughts exactly. As I've pointed out before, in a way the same is true of every player, that they have three modes of play: low, medium, and high, and that the greats are those that can play at the high level with frequency and rarely get to the low level. Someone like Monfils might be 30/40/30, Dolgopolov 60/30/10, whereas Federer c. 2006 might be 5/20/75, or c. 2015 be 20/50/30.
Or something like that.