nope. AO17 was a seminal moment. Roger finally realised he could lose the baggage. You seem to be stuck in the era where the match up was a serious problem for Roger. It hasn't been for a while. I don't think that Roger believed he would win that match in AO17
I mean.... there's a very clear 5 straight wins for Rafa in 2013 and 2014. So maybe go back just 4 years with your argument. But still. Roger is always gonna have mental scar tissue against Rafa.
I think you're saying that Roger has scar tissue against Rafa, when he doesn't. I feel like you're saying that how Novak plays against Rafa has relevance when he plays against Roger. It doesn't. Match ups matter
I'm not saying how Novak plays against Rafa matters. I never meant to say that. I was always trying to say that Novak doesn't matchup against Roger as well as he does against Rafa. BUT if he does play as well as he did tonight, because of matchup Fed may have gotten sets. But he's NOT winning. And the fact that he hasn't beaten Novak in their last.....
again... there you go again. You're saying given how he played against Rafa tonight he would have won. You simply cannot say that if you truly understand matchups. That's my point