MargaretMcAleer
The GOAT
- Joined
- Apr 30, 2013
- Messages
- 46,606
- Reactions
- 30,709
- Points
- 113
So True, but that’s more due to the crazy monopoly Novak has enjoyed at the AO and W and Rafa at the French in comparison. The USO winners since 2009 have really had just one relative outlier , Marin Cilic,’; all the other winners were multiple Slam finalists or prior Slam winners when they won at Flushing Meadows. Even Medvedev had been to 2 previous Slam finals & Theim to 3.I do agree if there's a BETTER chance for someone new to break through it may happen in NY.
Does Del Potro qualify as an outlier? He won in 2009.So True, but that’s more due to the crazy monopoly Novak has enjoyed at the AO and W and Rafa at the French in comparison. The USO winners since 2009 have really had just one relative outlier , Marin Cilic,’; all the other winners were multiple Slam finalists or prior Slam winners when they won at Flushing Meadows. Even Medvedev had been to 2 previous Slam finals & Theim to 3.
Sure Alcaraz won as a 19 year old, but to me now in hindsight winning Wimbledon he was going to burst out somewhere inevitably.
Happier news for AP lol! 76(5) 64Nice win by Murray over Nakashima. Big fight!
He said since 2009. So he's excluding JMDP w/ that statementDoes Del Potro qualify as an outlier? He won in 2009.
OK, I see that's where he drew the line, but I don't necessarily agree with it. JMDP's win is well in the Fedal years. The question is, as I see it, what makes the USO so hard to repeat? Surely last Major of the year is one of the problems. Or the biggest problem? It's why many, (including Nadal fans) thought he might never win it, back in the day. The Majors of the year are bracketed by HC tournaments. Why has Novak dominated the first one, and done even less well than Roger and Rafa at the last one? Why has New York seen so many first-time/only-time Slam winners, at least in, what, the past 20+ years? (I didn't check, but the FO may have had more if you go back past Nadal.) So, to AP's point, sure...why not a new winner?He said since 2009. So he's excluding JMDP w/ that statement
For goodnake sake, because the Big3 dominated the first 3 slams so thoroughly that they were tired/exhausted/less than peak by the time the 4th one rolled in.… Why has New York seen so many first-time/only-time Slam winners, at least in, what, the past 20+ years? (I didn't check, but the FO may have had more if you go back past Nadal.) So, to AP's point, sure...why not a new winner?
OK, now I see your point about them dominating the first 3 slams of the year, but I DID make the point about it being the last one, and fatigue being an issue. But then that doesn't account for Roger and Novak dominating the YEC. Novak, in particular, has often played a lot in the post USO season, and done well. Just not at the USO. But, sure, we agree that fatigue is an issue at the USO.For goodnake sake, because the Big3 dominated the first 3 slams so thoroughly that they were tired/exhausted/less than peak by the time the 4th one rolled in.
Sometimes the simple obvious reason works. ; )
First of all I don’t consider the YE ATP with it’s round robin best of 3 early round format the equivalent of the Slams plus *everyone* is running on fumes at that point, but whatever…OK, now I see your point about them dominating the first 3 slams of the year, but I DID make the point about it being the last one, and fatigue being an issue. But then that doesn't account for Roger and Novak dominating the YEC. Novak, in particular, has often played a lot in the post USO season, and done well. Just not at the USO. But, sure, we agree that fatigue is an issue at the USO.
Thanks MM,AP,
FAA continues to have a poor season going out to Watanuki ( #99) who played well, fearless tennis, in straight sets 76(10) 76 (3)
FAA knee appeared fine, though he should not be losing to these players that are lesser ranked..He has lost 6 out of his last 7 matches
It took you a while, but I'm glad that you're finally seeing the light. I used to be a fan of FAA (I no longer am), but I realized at some point this year that he just doesn't have it.Thanks MM,
Felix needs to make some changes very quickly...or he will have a free fall from his current high ranking.FAA overall tennis game is not good enough
Yeah it took me a minute...I don't enjoy being critical of FelixIt took you a while, but I'm glad that you're finally seeing the light. I used to be a fan of FAA (I no longer am), but I realized at some point this year that he just doesn't have it.
As @Jelenafan said, BO3 RR is a huge difference vs BO5. I would add indoor courts is another advantage that helped solidify end of season results for Djoke and Fed.OK, now I see your point about them dominating the first 3 slams of the year, but I DID make the point about it being the last one, and fatigue being an issue. But then that doesn't account for Roger and Novak dominating the YEC. Novak, in particular, has often played a lot in the post USO season, and done well. Just not at the USO. But, sure, we agree that fatigue is an issue at the USO.