I don't think you are getting the true meaning of what I meant. Ash Barley grass court game is so much better than anyone that is at the top of the tour. I wasn't campaigning for her to come out of retirement. However when Jordan first retired, he was burnt out but less than two years he was back again compete for titles. Never say it's over! Well at least I don't.
Sorry AP I went to bed when I now just saw your post to me. I would dismiss anything that 'poster said to you' regarding Ash Barty full stop
The poster never liked Barty even when she was a the top of her game, also having a snigger against her.,at any given chance
Hypothetically speaking if Barty and Iga playing now say on grass I would favor Barty as her game was made for grass.I feel at present Iga is not a natural grass courter though she has the weapons to do so.
Even though Barty won RG her least favored surface, I think Iga has a more natural game on clay
BTW H2H between Barty and Iga before Barty retired was Barty 2-0
Another point Ash had time away from tennis came back and proved what a great player she is.,when she said she was 'burnt out'
Remember too she was a 'child prodigy' had a lot of pressure to perform from the get go.
If she wanted to make a comeback, well that is her choice, I dont think she will, if she did I think she can rise to the top.Cream always rises to the top? dosent it?