Broken_Shoelace said:Riotbeard said:I think Serve and Volley was clearly the right decision. He got a sitter, and he missed it. No excuse for that. The idea that he should have let that ball float into a solid deep return is absurd.
It would have been absurd if the return was actually going to be solid and deep. But that clearly isn't the case. The ball would have been short and high bouncing. If this had been Federer, I'd say S & V is the right play. But when you're generally uncomfortable at the net, and don't serve and volley once the entire match, you don't do it on match point because then serving and volleying feels alien.
I agree with you. He must have done it instinctively out of nerves. Kind of like when Rafa served and volleyed when serving for the Wimbledon 2008 title.
He made it, so everyone sung his praises. Can only think of what people would say if he had missed and then been broken.