Sundaymorningguy said:
I always find it interesting when people say Serena had no rivals. I would say some key rivals were Capriati, Venus Williams and Henin. Capriati and Henin in particular usually gave her some tough quarterfinal matches. Serena lost quite a few tough 3 setters to Jennifer at RG and the tough one at the U.S. Open in 2004. She also lost a few QF to Justine namely 2007 when Justine really was in her stride. Venus as well I keep thinking about that 2008 Wimbledon where Serena had a break in both sets. Sure after 2009, the level of competition got interesting and Serena found her stride until injury hit. I would say 2012 and on is really where you can say she has no rival. She has many challenges, but no one consistently denying her titles like in years before 2011 I would say.
I agree. If Steffi's rival was Monica, Steffi won 22 Monica won 9 slams. Secondary rivals were Sanchez Vicarro who won 4, Sabatini won 1, and at the end Hingis who won 5.
Serena's rivals were Venus who won 7 slams, Justine who won 7 slams, Sharapova who won 5 slams, Clijsters who won 4, Kuznetsova who won 3, and Vika who won 2. All of those players had careers who were completely within Serena's careers.
Sure you could say Navratilova was technically within Steffi's time but her greatest triumphs weren't within Steffi's career.
Perhaps the best example of players who had to face a rival of equal historical significance is Navratilova who peaked with Chris Evert.
Still its silly to say Serena faced no rivals.