2015 Wimbledon SF: Sharapova Vs. Williams

Who takes it?

  • Maria in 2

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Maria in 3

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    11

tossip

Grand Slam Champion
Joined
Apr 15, 2013
Messages
7,297
Reactions
2,600
Points
113
will never feel sorry for pova because she is very cold.I remember the way she behaved when she was playing Golovina and this girl had broken her ankle,she never showed concern and continued practicing her serve......
 

colleen66

Pro Tour Champion
Joined
Apr 16, 2013
Messages
497
Reactions
0
Points
0
federberg said:
^I really don't think it's the surgery that's caused the serving issues. As I recall the surgery was on her right shoulder. Her problem is unquestionably her erratic ball toss. That's her left hand. It is a technical issue, which I would have thought should be relatively simple to fix, so it makes me wonder if there isn't a mental aspect to it. I mean really... how difficult is it to toss a ball up in a consistent way?
Federberg, I also remember reading that after 2004, Maria continued to grow at least 1-2 more inches and that growth "spurt" affected her center of gravity and started to influence her serving motion. If we couple that with the surgery, I could see how her serving mechanics might have gone off kilter.
 

Federberg

The GOAT
Joined
Apr 22, 2013
Messages
15,574
Reactions
5,662
Points
113
colleen66 said:
federberg said:
^I really don't think it's the surgery that's caused the serving issues. As I recall the surgery was on her right shoulder. Her problem is unquestionably her erratic ball toss. That's her left hand. It is a technical issue, which I would have thought should be relatively simple to fix, so it makes me wonder if there isn't a mental aspect to it. I mean really... how difficult is it to toss a ball up in a consistent way?
Federberg, I also remember reading that after 2004, Maria continued to grow at least 1-2 more inches and that growth "spurt" affected her center of gravity and started to influence her serving motion. If we couple that with the surgery, I could see how her serving mechanics might have gone off kilter.

It's possible I guess. But I'm still trying to understand how even a growth spurt could ruin her ball tossing technique. One of the graphics at Wimbledon this year showed the variation of her ball toss now in comparison to the early 2000s. Then it was a very tight bundle. Now it's all over the place. Because of this she is constantly having to adjust her contact point mid-serve. It can't be easy, but the root cause of the problem is the erratic ball toss
 

sk310

Masters Champion
Joined
Apr 17, 2013
Messages
905
Reactions
0
Points
0
jhar26 said:
Sundaymorningguy said:
I am a Serena fan, and I can admit her serve was never the same after surgery. Although, her record before her surgery shows that her game didn't make her a dominant force. 2004-2007 when Serena was average to poor Sharapova won 2 slams. That right there shows you that her game had limitations despite having a decent serve at the time. The big difference after the surgery was the double faults and the second serve fell apart which didn't help the limited scope of her game illustrated by the fact that she couldn't take advantage of Serena's low point and clean up at the slams.

Just because the procedure itself might not have been invasive, it doesn't mean that it didn't have a lasting effect on her.
Indeed. Sharapova's game has always had it's limitations, even when she was at her best. Perhaps it sounds a bit too harsh to call her a one trick pony (?). Not that it has prevented her from having a great career, because it's one hell of a trick when she's firing on all cilinders. Still, Serena is just too good for her. Even tenacity and fighting spirit can only take you so far. There's no shame in that. 12 years at the top of the most popular sport for women in the world is pretty awesome.

I think if anything the surgery helped her game. Sure you could argue that the shoulder surgery hurt her serve. You could also argue that the problems she had with her serve in the few years following her surgery forced her to finally develop other aspects of her game. From 2004-2008 when Maria was at pre-surgery peak the real dominant force in tennis was Henin. Sharapova was 3-7 against Henin. A player like Henin didn't rely on or have brute force but could expose Sharapova's weakness in movement and stamina. Her game plan was always to hit as hard as she could and end points quickly with as little movement as possible.

While Serena may be the hardest hitter in tennis she's also got the kind of tactical game and excellent movement that Henin had.

I think it's a little misleading to say that Sharapova ever really had an extended period of dominance in tennis as many commentators suggest.
 

jhar26

Pro Tour Champion
Joined
Apr 16, 2013
Messages
435
Reactions
1
Points
16
federberg said:
colleen66 said:
federberg said:
^I really don't think it's the surgery that's caused the serving issues. As I recall the surgery was on her right shoulder. Her problem is unquestionably her erratic ball toss. That's her left hand. It is a technical issue, which I would have thought should be relatively simple to fix, so it makes me wonder if there isn't a mental aspect to it. I mean really... how difficult is it to toss a ball up in a consistent way?
Federberg, I also remember reading that after 2004, Maria continued to grow at least 1-2 more inches and that growth "spurt" affected her center of gravity and started to influence her serving motion. If we couple that with the surgery, I could see how her serving mechanics might have gone off kilter.

It's possible I guess. But I'm still trying to understand how even a growth spurt could ruin her ball tossing technique. One of the graphics at Wimbledon this year showed the variation of her ball toss now in comparison to the early 2000s. Then it was a very tight bundle. Now it's all over the place. Because of this she is constantly having to adjust her contact point mid-serve. It can't be easy, but the root cause of the problem is the erratic ball toss
Yes, good point. I saw that as well. I'm perfectly willing to accept that the shoulder has had an impact on her serving arm. But there's no reason why it should affect her ball toss. Let's hope that she (or "her team") has seen that graphic as well, because that's definitely something she should and can work on.
 

kskate2

Administrator
Joined
Apr 14, 2013
Messages
31,033
Reactions
10,046
Points
113
Age
55
Location
Tampa Bay
Truth be told, her toss has been all over the place for years (even before the surgery). I think she had the yips back then. Seems like it all started early in the 2007 season. She was DF pretty regularly that year and sustained some fairly large beatdowns. During the off-season she worked on it because in Jan 08, she ran through the field at AO winning that one w/o dropping a set. But the DF numbers continued to plague her 08-09 and when she came back on the tour everyone assumed the DF's were because of the shoulder surgery, but that didn't affect the toss pre or post op.
 

Jelenafan

Multiple Major Winner
Joined
Sep 15, 2013
Messages
3,681
Reactions
5,029
Points
113
Location
California, USA
Pam Shriver said once you get the yips on your serve it's mental, and very hard to shake off.

Maria still relies on her first strike ability but Serena's defensive skills (still underrated by others IMO) negates that.

In a sense, it's the perfect storm for the head2head between Serena and Maria.

Maria has been so beatdown that it's almost a mental hurdle, her body language is not the most positive at all, and who can blame her? However, you can't discount that for whatever reasons, Serena is always "up" for playing Maria, and doesn't have the ocassional ugly meltdowns of downright patchy tennis in losses with other lower ranked players.
Whenever I see Maria in the draw verus Serena, it's almost guaranteed that Serena will be sharp and mentally alert for the matchup.
 

kskate2

Administrator
Joined
Apr 14, 2013
Messages
31,033
Reactions
10,046
Points
113
Age
55
Location
Tampa Bay
Jelenafan said:
Pam Shriver said once you get the yips on your serve it's mental, and very hard to shake off.

Maria still relies on her first strike ability but Serena's defensive skills (still underrated by others IMO) negates that.

In a sense, it's the perfect storm for the head2head between Serena and Maria.

Maria has been so beatdown that it's almost a mental hurdle, her body language is not the most positive at all, and who can blame her? However, you can't discount that for whatever reasons, Serena is always "up" for playing Maria, and doesn't have the ocassional ugly meltdowns of downright patchy tennis in losses with other lower ranked players.
Whenever I see Maria in the draw verus Serena, it's almost guaranteed that Serena will be sharp and mentally alert for the matchup.

And Pam would know wouldn't she? She had the yips many moons ago.

Welcome back to the board Yelenafan. You're a big fan of JJ? Wasn't her win over Petra vintage JJ?
 

Jelenafan

Multiple Major Winner
Joined
Sep 15, 2013
Messages
3,681
Reactions
5,029
Points
113
Location
California, USA
kskate2 said:
Jelenafan said:
Pam Shriver said once you get the yips on your serve it's mental, and very hard to shake off.

Maria still relies on her first strike ability but Serena's defensive skills (still underrated by others IMO) negates that.

In a sense, it's the perfect storm for the head2head between Serena and Maria.

Maria has been so beatdown that it's almost a mental hurdle, her body language is not the most positive at all, and who can blame her? However, you can't discount that for whatever reasons, Serena is always "up" for playing Maria, and doesn't have the ocassional ugly meltdowns of downright patchy tennis in losses with other lower ranked players.
Whenever I see Maria in the draw verus Serena, it's almost guaranteed that Serena will be sharp and mentally alert for the matchup.

And Pam would know wouldn't she? She had the yips many moons ago.

Welcome back to the board Yelenafan. You're a big fan of JJ? Wasn't her win over Petra vintage JJ?

OMG, Jelena's victory was so sweet. Yes it was vintage Jelena and it was glorious!! On grass to boost!
 

special700

Masters Champion
Joined
Jul 3, 2013
Messages
927
Reactions
1
Points
16
Jelenafan said:
Pam Shriver said once you get the yips on your serve it's mental, and very hard to shake off.

Maria still relies on her first strike ability but Serena's defensive skills (still underrated by others IMO) negates that.

In a sense, it's the perfect storm for the head2head between Serena and Maria.

Maria has been so beatdown that it's almost a mental hurdle, her body language is not the most positive at all, and who can blame her? However, you can't discount that for whatever reasons, Serena is always "up" for playing Maria, and doesn't have the ocassional ugly meltdowns of downright patchy tennis in losses with other lower ranked players.
Whenever I see Maria in the draw verus Serena, it's almost guaranteed that Serena will be sharp and mentally alert for the matchup.

that statement is so not true. Serena did not even play her best in that semi final and Maria still loss so your statement is so wrong
 

10isfan

Major Winner
Joined
Apr 16, 2013
Messages
1,944
Reactions
399
Points
83
I am sure Pova's team knows about the toss problem. There is not much that can be done about it. I might bet that her toss is perfectly fine during practice, but when she plays tournaments, it goes off.

Tennis is all about match ups. Whenever you get two players who have similar styles of play with one player slightly better in every department, scores can easily be lopsided. Serena and Pova are aggressive baseliners. Serena hits heavier balls (more spin and thus more margin) and has better movement and serves. Pova can't win unless Serena plays her C game.

The more interesting question is what should Pova do about her situation? Play a different style a la Cornet in an attempt to beat Serena and risk losing to many more players, or stick to her game and stay top five for a couple more years? So far, she is choosing the latter (probably to the frustration of Sven). He likely told her to drop shot at every chance. She hit one and sliced once in the entire match.
 

Kirijax

Grand Slam Champion
Joined
May 2, 2014
Messages
6,220
Reactions
4
Points
0
Age
60
Location
Kirishima, Japan
special700 said:
Jelenafan said:
Pam Shriver said once you get the yips on your serve it's mental, and very hard to shake off.

Maria still relies on her first strike ability but Serena's defensive skills (still underrated by others IMO) negates that.

In a sense, it's the perfect storm for the head2head between Serena and Maria.

Maria has been so beatdown that it's almost a mental hurdle, her body language is not the most positive at all, and who can blame her? However, you can't discount that for whatever reasons, Serena is always "up" for playing Maria, and doesn't have the ocassional ugly meltdowns of downright patchy tennis in losses with other lower ranked players.
Whenever I see Maria in the draw verus Serena, it's almost guaranteed that Serena will be sharp and mentally alert for the matchup.

that statement is so not true. Serena did not even play her best in that semi final and Maria still loss so your statement is so wrong

Serena is always up for Maria. I think it's pretty obvious. Despite the now lopsided record between the two, Serena is always up for a Sharapova beatdown. Just because she didn't play her best doesn't mean she wasn't up for it. Those are two different things. Gonna have to disagree with you there special700.
 

GameSetAndMath

The GOAT
Joined
Jul 9, 2013
Messages
21,141
Reactions
3,398
Points
113
federberg said:
colleen66 said:
federberg said:
^I really don't think it's the surgery that's caused the serving issues. As I recall the surgery was on her right shoulder. Her problem is unquestionably her erratic ball toss. That's her left hand. It is a technical issue, which I would have thought should be relatively simple to fix, so it makes me wonder if there isn't a mental aspect to it. I mean really... how difficult is it to toss a ball up in a consistent way?
Federberg, I also remember reading that after 2004, Maria continued to grow at least 1-2 more inches and that growth "spurt" affected her center of gravity and started to influence her serving motion. If we couple that with the surgery, I could see how her serving mechanics might have gone off kilter.

It's possible I guess. But I'm still trying to understand how even a growth spurt could ruin her ball tossing technique. One of the graphics at Wimbledon this year showed the variation of her ball toss now in comparison to the early 2000s. Then it was a very tight bundle. Now it's all over the place. Because of this she is constantly having to adjust her contact point mid-serve. It can't be easy, but the root cause of the problem is the erratic ball toss

Perhaps, WTA should consider allowing the coach or the hitting partner to toss the ball. :snicker
 

special700

Masters Champion
Joined
Jul 3, 2013
Messages
927
Reactions
1
Points
16
Kirijax said:
special700 said:
Jelenafan said:
Pam Shriver said once you get the yips on your serve it's mental, and very hard to shake off.

Maria still relies on her first strike ability but Serena's defensive skills (still underrated by others IMO) negates that.

In a sense, it's the perfect storm for the head2head between Serena and Maria.

Maria has been so beatdown that it's almost a mental hurdle, her body language is not the most positive at all, and who can blame her? However, you can't discount that for whatever reasons, Serena is always "up" for playing Maria, and doesn't have the ocassional ugly meltdowns of downright patchy tennis in losses with other lower ranked players.
Whenever I see Maria in the draw verus Serena, it's almost guaranteed that Serena will be sharp and mentally alert for the matchup.

that statement is so not true. Serena did not even play her best in that semi final and Maria still loss so your statement is so wrong

Serena is always up for Maria. I think it's pretty obvious. Despite the now lopsided record between the two, Serena is always up for a Sharapova beatdown. Just because she didn't play her best doesn't mean she wasn't up for it. Those are two different things. Gonna have to disagree with you there special700.

We agree to disagree.
 

kskate2

Administrator
Joined
Apr 14, 2013
Messages
31,033
Reactions
10,046
Points
113
Age
55
Location
Tampa Bay
special700 said:
Jelenafan said:
Pam Shriver said once you get the yips on your serve it's mental, and very hard to shake off.

Maria still relies on her first strike ability but Serena's defensive skills (still underrated by others IMO) negates that.

In a sense, it's the perfect storm for the head2head between Serena and Maria.

Maria has been so beatdown that it's almost a mental hurdle, her body language is not the most positive at all, and who can blame her? However, you can't discount that for whatever reasons, Serena is always "up" for playing Maria, and doesn't have the ocassional ugly meltdowns of downright patchy tennis in losses with other lower ranked players.
Whenever I see Maria in the draw verus Serena, it's almost guaranteed that Serena will be sharp and mentally alert for the matchup.

that statement is so not true. Serena did not even play her best in that semi final and Maria still loss so your statement is so wrong

Just because someone doesn't agree w/ you doesn't make them wrong. Being wrong would be equal to a misstatement of the facts, not your personal opinion.
 

Jelenafan

Multiple Major Winner
Joined
Sep 15, 2013
Messages
3,681
Reactions
5,029
Points
113
Location
California, USA
The thing that also stood out to me is that Maria was guessing way too much on Serena's serve and did absolutely nothing to change up her game to give Serena at least a different look.

More than anything, Maria looks resigned that she will lose if Serena is playing well, but one would think that Maria would be willing to try something different. I mean, drop shot, slice, hit more in the middle of the court, come to net, ANYTHING, to shake things up. She's lost 17 straight matches in 11 years and counting and is not closing the gap, the status quo is not helping her at all. If she's going to lose, at least lose with some variety.

It goes back that for all her gifts, Maria can't really change up her game, she simply doesn't possess genuine variety.
 

Kirijax

Grand Slam Champion
Joined
May 2, 2014
Messages
6,220
Reactions
4
Points
0
Age
60
Location
Kirishima, Japan
Jelenafan said:
The thing that also stood out to me is that Maria was guessing way too much on Serena's serve and did absolutely nothing to change up her game to give Serena at least a different look.

More than anything, Maria looks resigned that she will lose if Serena is playing well, but one would think that Maria would be willing to try something different. I mean, drop shot, slice, hit more in the middle of the court, come to net, ANYTHING, to shake things up. She's lost 17 straight matches in 11 years and counting and is not closing the gap, the status quo is not helping her at all. If she's going to lose, at least lose with some variety.

It goes back that for all her gifts, Maria can't really change up her game, she simply doesn't possess genuine variety.

That really stood out for me too. She had absolutely no idea where Serena's serve was coming. So many time we saw her stepping in the wrong way. And she did have that resigned look on her face.