federberg said:
Moose said:
Moxie629 said:
Not even. What will it signify? If Novak wins, he's already #1. If Rafa wins, he's still the best at RG and still #6 or whatever. Wimbledon 08 was a changing of the guard.
I respectfully disagree. You are talking about the greatest clay courter of all time - if Nole wins this match, I think it's a changing of the guard as well.
Soderling's win was a fluke. Nole's win would be a dethroning.
That was NOT a fluke. Not having it. Soderling did what Stanimal did yesterday in conducive conditions. Please do not diminish a career match :nono
I should clarify - I did not mean fluke in terms of the win, because Robin totally outplayed Rafa. I meant more in the sense of the history of tennis. Soderling's win did not change the power structure, since Rafa went on to win the next 5 French titles. And no one referred to Robin afterward as the top ATP player on clay.
My personal felling is that if Novak wins today, it's a change in the power structure - I think then Novak becomes, with the title, the best clay player in the the game today. Not dismissing Rafa's incredible history here, only saying that for the present moment, Novak has taken over as the best ATPer on clay.