the AntiPusher said:
Here is my two cents.. when I was a kid growing up, there would be some dogs that wasnt just naturally tough or mean enough to be thought of as guard dogs. There was a myth if you fed the dogs gunpowder, it would make the animal mean or tougher. Sloane isnt a naturally born killer such as "Serena, Sharapova, Venus or Henin" and I truly dont think this can be taught by a coach. Annacone can improve the fundamentals of her game but I am not sure that he can teach her to be mentally tough against the top 10 players consistently. I think Sloane may be the female version of some of the Men's players such as Tommy Haas, David Nalby or Berdych, players who had the talent but not the inner mental strength to put their foot on someone's throat if needed. Look at Sloane's match results, she rarely annihilate her opponents. IMO
You may be correct, but also consider that not every great player's killer instinct was always on the surface. Sometimes it needed to be exposed, and a coach helped this process. If you had been around Federer during his junior years, when he was a notorious hot head, crying and screaming on court, you would never have thought, "This guy is going to win 17 Majors." There's no denying the killer instinct was there, but it needed to be nurtured.
I'm not saying Sloane is going to win 17 Majors, but she might end up winning more than if she had never hooked up with Annacone. Who knows. All I'm saying is I'm not writing her off yet.