Congratulations to Serena, just the 4th tennis player to be named sportsperson. :clap :clap :clap
Well, the internet is crazy with controversy over this award. So far no body has bothered to speak up here.
I am actually ambivalent here.
If it is strictly "sportsperson of this year", I think it should either go to Novak or at least be shared with Novak (I am not even going to bother to talk about horses and other sports). IMHO, Novak was more dominant this year than Serena, even though in terms of pure win-loss percentage, Serena outdid Novak.
Afterall, Serena won as many grand slams as she lost matches in 2016, both being three.
However, the "sportsperson of this year" should not be taken literally. These are at least in part life time achievement awards. In that case, Serena clearly deserves it and also clearly deserves to win it exclusively (Novak has long road to travel before he can get such a glorious award, in terms of lifetime achievement). This is somewhat akin to not giving Heisman trophy to the best performer in an year, saying that he is just a freshmen and he can always in it in the next year or so.
To me this year is particularly well suited to give Serena this award due to the following three reasons.
1. This is the year in which Serena achieved her second Serena Slam (Novak has not yet achieved career slam, not to mention about Novak Slam).
2. Serena showed lot of class, courage and heart in returning to IW this year after 14 years of self-imposed exile (Note: Sportsperson of the year also considers off court accomplishments).
3. It is highly unlikely (although I am not saying impossible) that Serena will have a better year in her remaining career (due to her age and health, not due to competition). Given that this may be the case, it is better to bestow her this award this year instead of doing it couple of years down the road when she wins just one slam and overtakes Graf or Court.