I don't know if the "mysteriousness" of the virus argues against having tried for a vaccine. Sure, the vaccine was no miracle. But no one can say that it wasn't effective at abating symptoms, which it seems to have been. You can disagree, but you can't prove it, any more than I can prove the opposite.
Nobody is saying they shouldn't
try for a vaccine. It's the vaccine itself which many people have valid queries about, as you acknowledge yourself. It didn't perform as advertised and of course, since the virus is so mysterious, how could it? If it was so successful, this could be easily proven, but we both agree on this. I also agree that it has done more good than its most extreme critics will concede.
That's a bit mean to say that your brother and his partner got sick, and that's the "good news," but I take your point.
Well, I'm glad you got the point. When I say they got a severe dose, he was sniffling for a few days and she was in bed for a week. That was a drastically different outcome than they felt they'd been promised. It had the effect of stopping them haranguing and upsetting other family members, in both their families.
I think during Covid, at the extremities there were two camps. One camp shouted
TRUST THE SCIENCE and were on the spectrum for favouring mandates, stronger government controls, and basically allowing others in authority to do their thinking for them, while at the same time arguing in favour of big government measures that badly effected peoples lives, their livelihoods and their freedoms, and most of this was unnecessary. Within this camp there were people who compared Covid to the lovechild of the black death and the Ten Plagues of Egypt.
The other camp, at the other extreme, shouted
WAKE UP SHEEPLE and argued against all the above, while at the same time dismissing Covid as being a mere sniffle. Both of these camps existed for the same reasons, I believe, and it's that people were shocked at what was happening and were seeking an external authority to help them understand.
Big-pharma IS a problem here, I won't deny that, and there are lots of books and documentaries to that effect. I won't get into the politics of what that stems from. But if we're exporting that to you, and you accept it, that's on your country. You have self-determination.
I agree with you, but good luck in getting that to work in practice. The imitative factor when it comes to behaviours is strong. I've often thought that if each nations political discourse was embodied in song, US politics would be a catchy, gyrating tune that you can't get out of your head, with banal lyrics that are nonetheless infectious. I could list you all the ways that bad ideas from the American left and right have been aped by westerners to disastrous effect, but this isn't that thread. Ultimately, I agree with you. It's up to people to learn how to discern how to apply ideas to their own circumstance. What happens in America is particular to that country, to a very large, real time extent.
You've said that more than once. So I'll repeat myself, too. Flu vaccines are long-proven. Flu (influenza,) which is NOT the common cold, kills between 290,000 and 650,00 per year. It kills the very young, the very old, and the immunocompromised. It's not coming for you, but you can give it to others. I know you don't believe that the vaccine against it helps staunch the spread, but I do. Do you not believe that vaccination against polio helps staunch the spread? Or that the vaccination against measles and rubella are effective? Influenza is not an inconsiderable disease. A simple jab against influenza, which arguably doesn't hurt you, could protect the more vulnerable to it. May I ask, what do you have against the flu jab? Are you against the others I named?
I'm aware of all this as we have discussed it several times, but I trust my immune system to deal with the flu. The other vaccine examples you gave are irrelevant because they're not disputed by me, and they don't require me to take them annually. I limit my exposures to pharmaceutical medicines. If I catch a flu - and it's been decades since I have - then I limit my exposure to people, too. If the flu jab isn't protecting the vulnerable, then neither can I...