ricardo said:
El Dude said:
Good, because something needs to change. Out in the R64 of Shanghai? What a disappointment he is. I know, Nishikori is a good player but he's the type of player that Grigor should be beating by now. Let's hope that 2014 show a breakthrough, because if not I'm afraid he's not going to be anything more than a top 20ish player.
really? he might be a slight fav if performance is up to scratch, but 'should be' is only if you are a very very heavy favorite. He is not.
Let me put it slightly differently. Kei Nishikori has, for the most part, reached his potential. He might peek into the top 10 now and then, but I think he's pretty much the definition of a "third tier" player - the type of player that is regularly ranked in the top 20, but rarely in the top 10 and (almost/probably) never in the top 5. Think Gilles Simon, Juan Monaco, Nicolas Almagro, Mikhail Youzhny.
Grigor Dimitrov has the
potential to be more - a "second tier" player - someone regularly ranked in the top 10, occasionally reaching the top 5, and a darkhorse candidate at Slams and ATP 1000s; think Tomas Berdych, Jo-Wilfried Tsonga, David Ferrer, David Nalbandian, etc. He's not there yet - he's not even a third tier player at this point - but he should get there. And even that is somewhat disappointing from his earlier promise (or hype) - as a bonafide "first tier" player; a top 5 regular who wins a Slam or three.
We still don't know what Grigor is going to be. Right now he looks like he's another Cilic or Gasquet - an underachiever who settles in more as a 3rd tier player (although to be fair to Gasquet, he's at least knocking at the door of 2nd tier these days). Most 1st tier players were at least 2nd tier by the time they were Dimitrov's age, which makes it very unlikely he'll ever be a true elite. But the promise is still there to be 2nd tier.
So when I said Dimitrov "should be" beating players like Nishikori, I mean to say that
if he were on the developmental schedule that we thought, or hoped, he would be on, then he should be
at least beating third tier players more often than not by now (at age 22); at this point he's still a "fourth tier" player - ranked in the 20-50 range, going deep in lower level tournaments with one or two better performances at higher tournaments, but no signs of being serious contenders to win more than the occasional ATP 250.