Did Del Potro Play The Greatest Tennis We Ever Saw?

scoop

Major Winner
Joined
Aug 8, 2013
Messages
1,417
Reactions
172
Points
63


By Scoop Malinowski

Roger Federer is generally considered the greatest tennis player of all time and his record breaking achievements certainly support that notion.

Twenty major titles, regaining the ATP World No. ranking again at age 36 are accomplishments that may never be equaled.

Yes Roger Federer has to be consider the greatest of all time. But did he play the greatest tennis we ever saw?

It has been argued that Novak Djokovic, when at his best, uplifted tennis to a new height, above and beyond Federer and Rafael Nadal. Djokovic’s unbelievable defense and agility and movement and counterpunching and mental strength and burning desire to win made him a nightmare for any player to have to contend with. Djokovic even beat Nadal eight times in a row in finals, one of the most incredible achievements in tennis history.

But an outside, uncoventional view that has to be considered is the Juan Martin Del Potro factor. The Might Argentine has shown many times he is a special colossus of the court, with an abundance of power in his arsenal that has proven on many occasions that it’s too much for even Federer, Nadal and Djokovic to handle and deal with.

When Del Potro is at his best, in full health and operating in his optimum zone level, he has blasted prime Fed, Nadal and Djokovic off the court, even reducing the Serbian to tears after their 2016 Olympics clash of titans in Brazil.

Most recently, Del Potro blasted Federer off the court at last year’s US Open but was a faded version in the next round against Nadal, having been drained in the previous round five setter vs Dominic Thiem.

But it’s entirely possible that Del Potro at his most potent, powerful, pinpoint best is actually too much for Fed, Rafa and Djokovic. Del Potro is the only player who has the capacity to inflict devastation on Fed, Rafa and Djokovic. He can’t do it all the time because he simply cannot sustain his magical level of play except for only rare and special occasions.

Usually Del Potro is at his best in the big events on the big stage stadiums, where his singing supporters have a special ability to uplift and inspire Del Potro to raise his level. I have witnessed this on many occasions. Last year at the US Open vs Federer, the Argentine fans sang just once each late in the first set and then in the third set tiebreaker and mysteriously, Del Potro responded on cue by suddenly raising his level to take each set. It was uncanny to experience.

if only Federer, Nadal and Djokovic had fans that sang for him to produce and inspire even greater tennis. But they don’t. Only Del Potro has that secret weapon.

We may never know the real true answer but I think it’s possible, and nobody can discount this opinion, that Juan Martin Del Potro, when at his very best, could be the most potent, explosive, devastating…greatest tennis player we ever saw.

Don’t even try to shoot down this assertion. I have seen Del Potro annihilate Federer, Rafa and Djokovic too many times to concede on this. Yes, Fed, Rafa and Djokovic are three of the greatest of all time with Fed on top of the list. But when big Juan Martin Del Potro is in the mood and the stars are aligned, he might produce the best tennis in history.

I plan on discussing this topic with the humble tennis mastermind Del Potro this week in Delray Beach.
 

scoop

Major Winner
Joined
Aug 8, 2013
Messages
1,417
Reactions
172
Points
63
Scoop Malinowski writes:

There is more penetration and blunt force on Delpo's forehand strikes than any other player. When he's firing on all cylinders, he makes other players helpless, even Fed, Rafa and Nadal. When his timing and confidence are off he can lose to journeyman. Not much unlike the old time baseball slugger Reggie Jackson or Dave Kingman or Adam Dunn. Del Potro, if he had been born in America and played baseball, would have been a MLB home run king.
 

scoop

Major Winner
Joined
Aug 8, 2013
Messages
1,417
Reactions
172
Points
63
Scoop Malinowski writes:

Kyrgios is out with arm inj. This changes draw and now Sock will play JP Smith, Raonic is now 9 seed and escapes having to play Sock yet again :) Sock plays tomorrow night as does Young vs the young Indian Ramanathan.
 

Haelfix

Pro Tour Player
Joined
Apr 22, 2013
Messages
334
Reactions
65
Points
28
This is the 'if player X was playing at his best vs player Y, who is better'.

And its a nasty question to answer, b/c I submit to you that John Isner beats everyone, simply b/c he would hit only aces and all he has to do is go for broke on three returns in a 5 set match.

If you look at sustained level of play throughout a GS match or a tournament, there are probably a few candidates. Del Potro's USO2009 would be one of them. So would Federer's 2007 AO and 2004 Wimbledon, Safin's USO win, Nadal's RG 2008 and his USO 2010, Djokovic and his 2011 AO, maybe Pat Rafter in his first USO win or Sampras in one of his wimbledon romps. But who beats who, is one of those impossible questions that depends on too many variables to even be able to broach.
 

El Dude

The GOAT
Joined
Apr 14, 2013
Messages
10,128
Reactions
5,777
Points
113
Wait, didn't you write an article saying pretty much the same thing about Kyrgios just a few weeks ago? Is it "best player ever of the month?" ;)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Front242

Federberg

The GOAT
Joined
Apr 22, 2013
Messages
15,542
Reactions
5,607
Points
113
This is the 'if player X was playing at his best vs player Y, who is better'.

And its a nasty question to answer, b/c I submit to you that John Isner beats everyone, simply b/c he would hit only aces and all he has to do is go for broke on three returns in a 5 set match.

If you look at sustained level of play throughout a GS match or a tournament, there are probably a few candidates. Del Potro's USO2009 would be one of them. So would Federer's 2007 AO and 2004 Wimbledon, Safin's USO win, Nadal's RG 2008 and his USO 2010, Djokovic and his 2011 AO, maybe Pat Rafter in his first USO win or Sampras in one of his wimbledon romps. But who beats who, is one of those impossible questions that depends on too many variables to even be able to broach.

I would replace Federer's 04 Wimbledon with the one in 07. Can't see how Nadal's 2010 makes the grade. Safin was awesome in the final, but through the tournament I can't say it was especially dominant. I would add McEnroe's Wimbledon 84. But truth to tell, Nadal's RG 08 is tough to beat
 
  • Like
Reactions: Moxie

britbox

Multiple Major Winner
Joined
Apr 14, 2013
Messages
27,403
Reactions
6,211
Points
113
Location
Gold Coast, Australia
^ I'd definitely have Nadal's USO 2010 in there. McEnroe's 84 Wimbledon is a given...Maybe Edberg's '92 US Open - not for dominance, but certainly sustained level of play. He was basically winning 5 set matches from a 5th set break down against Hall of Famers in three consecutive matches before drubbing Sampras in the final.
 

Federberg

The GOAT
Joined
Apr 22, 2013
Messages
15,542
Reactions
5,607
Points
113
^ I'd definitely have Nadal's USO 2010 in there. McEnroe's 84 Wimbledon is a given...Maybe Edberg's '92 US Open - not for dominance, but certainly sustained level of play. He was basically winning 5 set matches from a 5th set break down against Hall of Famers in three consecutive matches before drubbing Sampras in the final.

perhaps my memory's a bit foggy but who did Rafa face?

by the way, I'm pretty sure there are a number of Borg runs I haven't included
 

Moxie

Multiple Major Winner
Joined
Apr 14, 2013
Messages
43,626
Reactions
14,784
Points
113
perhaps my memory's a bit foggy but who did Rafa face?

by the way, I'm pretty sure there are a number of Borg runs I haven't included
You're not wrong to question the inclusion of Nadal's USO 2010, imo. Even though he only lost one set in the tourney (in the final, to Djokovic) he didn't face strong competition. Murray lost early and Berdych lost to Simon. It was a very great Rafa, with his best serve ever, but not a strong opposition. (I remember a lot of disgruntlement over a "cupcake draw," at the time, which I do object to, but fair is fair.) The greatest thing about it was that he saw an opportunity and he didn't let it pass him by. I agree with you changing Roger's 2004 Wimbledon for his 2007 one. Also, I think Rafa's 2008 MC gets forgotten, where he was untouchable, in the face of his RG that year, which was also pretty immaculate. You're right to say some Borg ones must qualify, though I haven't got one off the top of my head, either.
 

Front242

The GOAT
Joined
Apr 14, 2013
Messages
22,963
Reactions
3,897
Points
113
He lost in the final to Federer but Fernando Gonzalez played some incredible matches at the 2007 AO. cali won't be happy to see no mention of Nalbandian either. From the baseline I'd take prime Nalbandian even with his crap serve any day over prime pre wrist surgeries Del Potro.
 

I.Haychew

Major Winner
Joined
Apr 15, 2013
Messages
1,148
Reactions
176
Points
63
Best tennis ever = Nalbandian at the 2007 Paris Masters. Do best of threes count?
 
  • Like
Reactions: isabelle

Haelfix

Pro Tour Player
Joined
Apr 22, 2013
Messages
334
Reactions
65
Points
28
Yea I wasn't including level at a masters cup b/c that would open the door for a lot of players.
I'd also really only talk about actual 'level of play' and not about who they face. Which is why Nadals USO 2011 and Federers Wimbledon 2004 should be up there. Federer's grass play was never better than that tourney, nor was Nadals hardcourt skills (and serve strangely enough).

McEnroe's 84 wimbledon definitely has to be included as well...
A case can be made for Goran's wimbledon as well. There are probably a bunch of great clay courters that i'm leaving out, b/c they all seem to be trumped by Nadal's brilliance.
 

Andy22

Major Winner
Joined
Feb 2, 2018
Messages
1,975
Reactions
488
Points
83
Location
Australia
Rafael nadal 2013/10 seasons was the highest level of tennis I have never seen.
 

Busted

Major Winner
Joined
Dec 23, 2013
Messages
1,281
Reactions
412
Points
83
Wait, didn't you write an article saying pretty much the same thing about Kyrgios just a few weeks ago? Is it "best player ever of the month?" ;)

I've given up on Scoop and his OTT hyperbole. If DelPo was so much better than Roger, Nadal and Nole in his prime years - then why does he have a losing record against all of them? And did even before his wrist injuries. He's a combined 15-41 against the 3 of them. NEXT!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Andy22

Busted

Major Winner
Joined
Dec 23, 2013
Messages
1,281
Reactions
412
Points
83
Rafael nadal 2013/10 seasons was the highest level of tennis I have never seen.

Of course it is. And for you the fact that Federer and Djokovic have both had MULTIPLE better seasons is a pink unicorn pooping purple diamonds...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Horsa

Andy22

Major Winner
Joined
Feb 2, 2018
Messages
1,975
Reactions
488
Points
83
Location
Australia
Of course it is. And for you the fact that Federer and Djokovic have both had MULTIPLE better seasons is a pink unicorn pooping purple diamonds...
Nadal won 3 Slams in a row in the some season, Federer, djokovic best seasons did not ever do that.
 

coban

Futures Player
Joined
Apr 15, 2013
Messages
102
Reactions
1
Points
18
The answer is no. The best Tennis we ever saw was Tsonga vs. Nadal in AO 2008.

(edit: wrong year)
 
Last edited:

britbox

Multiple Major Winner
Joined
Apr 14, 2013
Messages
27,403
Reactions
6,211
Points
113
Location
Gold Coast, Australia
The answer is no. The best Tennis we ever saw was Tsonga vs. Nadal in AO 2007.

2008 but agreed that it was an insane performance by Tsonga. Don't think he's ever replicated that level. Not sure about it being the best ever, but it was definitely Tsonga's best ever.
 

coban

Futures Player
Joined
Apr 15, 2013
Messages
102
Reactions
1
Points
18
2008 but agreed that it was an insane performance by Tsonga. Don't think he's ever replicated that level. Not sure about it being the best ever, but it was definitely Tsonga's best ever.

C'mon, look at the high-light reel and tell me this ain't some alien level. Atleast for a full match, this is the best i remember. But i also remember Federer thrashing Del-Po in AO 09, maybe Del-Potro was injuried, i can't recall.
 

scoop

Major Winner
Joined
Aug 8, 2013
Messages
1,417
Reactions
172
Points
63
Scoop Malinowski writes:

Busted, Delpo is not better but he can play a higher level of tennis only infrequently though. Delpo rarely hits his seventh gear but when he does he has shown he can blast Rafa, Fed, Djokovic off the court. That is what I'm saying. Kyrgios has that capacity too. When Kyrgios is at his best he can manhandle Fed, Rafa and Djokovic. When Kyrgios is not at his best, which is most of the time, he's closer to ordinary than extraordinary. That's the point I'm making.